How to stand out & provoke.
5 reasons prospects don't reply
Here’s what we’re learning from our Academy students (sales reps & business owners).
Cold emails and InMails fail to start discussions because they:
- blend in, are clearly mass e-mailed;
- have subject lines telegraphing what’s inside; (never get opened)
- focus on the seller;
- ask for a meeting;
- contain Web links or PDFs. (distracting customers from replying OR causing the message to be spam binned!)
In 93% of cases our Academy members report lack of response because the sender’s goal is focused on earning a meeting. Everything (bad) flows from this flawed objective.
Instead, provoke a short discussion … that MIGHT (if the client decides) lead to a meeting.
Then, conduct the conversation (via email) in a way that creates an urge in good prospects … to ask you for the appointment. Poor prospects will fall away.
All because of how you structured words.
Write subject lines this way
Focus your subject lines on creating a tension. Yes, tension.
Tension creates curiosity.
The job of your subject line is to create curiosity about what’s inside the message. Nothing more.
Don’t focus on pain points. If you do, you’ll blend in with the pack. EVERYONE is doing this. Trust me. Avoid it.
Don’t be cute. This always causes trouble.
Be careful about using first names in subject lines. This is often a signal of “fake personalization.” Some buyers are VERY savvy to mail merged spam!
Make your subject line:
- Familiar yet also vague (don’t be overtly specific)
- Provocative … a little bit weird … yet credible
- As short as possible (2-3 words is best)
Never, ever trick with your subject lines. No using “RE:” or any of that kiddie stuff.
Never ever ask for what you want in the subject line. (e.g. can we talk?) Avoid asking yes/no questions.
Eliminate self-talk
This is often the most difficult part. For some of our students it feels natural, others it’s uncomfortable.
Take your marketing hat off. Leave it where you’ll never find it again!
Abandon any old habits of leaning on marketing prose found on web sites, etc. And beware of taking sales writing advice from marketing folks.
Here is a quick example of a “before and after” from a student we helped recently. He struggled terribly. But when I asked him, “what are the blood-and-guts, ugly issues your customers are struggling with” everything changed. We finally had a few trigger words, strong issues to provoke with.
Pay attention to all the self-talk in the BEFORE below … and how desperate Homer sounds when he says, “I would love to give you a quick intro to the service” then asks for the call TOO SOON.
Under-performing draft
Message
Analysis
Subject: PRODUCT NAME -- meeting request ❶
Hi, Susan.
Whether your vehicle fleet is public or private, small, medium, or large, PRODUCT NAME enables you to track, monitor, and manage your fleet efficiently and effectively. ❷
Onboard vehicle diagnostics, GPS tracking, and roadside assistance are just some of the PRODUCT NAME features that will help you keep your business operating at peak performance. ❸
I would love to give you a quick intro to the service. Are you available this Monday for a 20 minute call? ❹
Best regards,
Homer Simpson
❶ Subject line: Stating what sender wants: Meeting about what they're selling. Get in line! Customers delete many of these daily, appreciates making easy to spot!
❷ Opener: Clearly a "cut-and-paste template" due to zero customization. Delete! Pure marketing speak. Nothing provoking curiosity. You hate emails like this... that read like TV ad scripts. Your prospects do too.
❸ Meat: Lists features that may not be valued by the prospect. Lacks curiosity tactic. Read this with your best "radio announcer voice." Literally. It's that bad, right?!
❹ Closer: Never, ever say you would love or hope in a cold email. These weak words risk you appearing needy. Avoid asking for meetings at all costs for many reasons.
Performing draft
Message
Analysis
Subject: Which hurts more? ❶
Hi, Susan.
What do you have in place -- to stop employee vehicle abuse? Like using vehicles for personal use. Or speeding, slamming on brakes... driving aggressively. Which hurts more? ❷
Most Portland area construction companies do nothing. Vehicle abuse is effecting your brand image, safety and expenses. ❸
Are you open to considering an unusual (but effective) tactic to prevent vehicle abuse? ❹
Best regards,
Homer Simpson
Notice: The message focuses only on the customer...
not the seller's goals, products/services.
❶ Subject line: Has tension. Provokes thoughts: "Which of what hurts?" Customer needs to open to understand.
❷ Opener: Questions are dangerous. Most are set-ups to pitches. But this type of "facilitative" question helps buyers consider the status quo. It does not lead to an answer the seller wants. Instead, it uses "blood-and-guts" description of relevant struggles clients usually are unable to fix.
❸ Localization & industry customization: Always increases response. Helps offset how this is a Tailored (one-to-many) email with a personalized tone. Calls brand image (not so obvious) into question, not just expenses.
❹ Closer: Uses "unusual" as a trigger word. ("What is so unusual about it?) Asks if client is open minded, not jumping-the-gun on a meeting.
Want to learn these techniques and more ... and start practicing them with us?
Prospecting expert, Jed Fleming and I will guide you in a Master Class or learn the basics in our online Academy.
Will Targeted work for me?
Standing out in the inbox using a Targeted approach is very difficult. Because everyone knows what a mass-emailed message feels like when we see it. It’s almost instantaneous. But there are emerging tactics our private community can teach you.
- Do you know the market well?
- Able to localize your offering to a region.
- Chasing after a niche market within an outreach campaign? (as seen in the example above)
- Can you talk “blood-and-guts” about problems your customers struggle to solve … or may not realize they have? (yet)
- Need to get conversations started at scale?
Targeted (one-to-many) Spark provocation may work for you.
There are dangers. Such as pushing “pain points.” Be very careful about playing on them in messages. In fact, don’t. Just don’t. Doing so usually backfires. EVERYONE is doing this. You don’t want to look common.
How you go about writing is the key to success.
Every word counts. And with the Spark technique less is more.
Not sure what the difference is between a Tailored (one-to-one) and a Targeted message? This is vital to your success. Get in touch so I, or my support team, can get you on track.
Or ask in comments below if you have questions.
Message sequences must avoid this
Meeting requests. Just stop!
When you begin an email sequence trying for an appointment you will be rejected by 90 – 97% of perfectly good prospects. Most buyers don’t know precisely what they need when you email them. Or—if they do have a need—they aren’t ready to buy yet. Example: If it’s a complex purchase, your target may not have assembled the decision-making team yet.
Setting an appointment with a seller will happen—but not with you.
Because you asked for it. (too early)
Instead, hold a little back. This creates curiosity. This helps attract the appointment to you.
The buyer will see the appointment as a way to short-circuit all the emailing.
Less is more.
The biggest challenge: Making your campaign NOT feel campaign-like. And avoiding the popular (but failing best practice) of “adding value in every message.”
Common practice. Fails like crazy.
Nee help applying an effective technique in your setting? Join us in an upcoming 8-week, intensive Master Class + Coaching. We only have a few seats left and are taking 10 students maximum… so we can spend time helping each of you develop provocations.
© Communications Edge Inc. All rights reserved. InMail® is a registered trademark of LinkedIn® Corporation. This site and the products and services offered on this site are not associated, affiliated, endorsed, or sponsored by Linkedin, nor have they been reviewed, tested or certified by LinkedIn.

